Cover of All the Colors of the Dark

All the Colors of the Dark

by Chris Whitaker


Genre
Mystery, Crime, Suspense
Year
2024
Pages
865
Contents

Chapter 166

Overview

Patch’s first night with Charlotte shows how unprepared he feels for fatherhood and how deep Charlotte’s grief and resistance still run. Sammy’s visit brings back the unresolved pressures of Patch’s old life—his art, Marty Tooms, and the search for Callie—but Patch cannot return to who he was. By the end, a news report about random violence sharpens his new fear: keeping Charlotte safe has become the most immediate and fragile responsibility of his life.

Summary

On Charlotte’s first night in his house, Patch tries to care for her carefully but gets almost everything wrong. He makes pizza because he worries about takeout, but Charlotte rejects it, compares his cooking to her mother’s, and also refuses the orange juice and improvised banana split he offers. Unsure how to handle even basic routines, Patch runs her a bath and calls Sammy to ask what time she usually goes to bed.

Patch also tries to make Charlotte comfortable by giving her a new television, but she abruptly withdraws upstairs instead. After waiting, he finds her lying in bed turned away from him. Although Charlotte dismisses stories as childish, Patch tells her one anyway, describing the long roads he traveled because a lost girl had once spoken to him about places across California and Alaska; the story reveals how deeply his past search still shapes him.

Patch sits outside Charlotte’s bedroom door, listening for her breathing, until Sammy arrives. In the backyard, Sammy drinks Blue Label and mentions a New York offer connected to “Grace Number One,” but Patch shows no interest. When Sammy asks whether everything stops now, Patch admits that he sees himself in Charlotte and confesses that he does not know how to be a parent; Sammy reframes that fear as something Patch can learn, just as he once learned to paint.

The conversation turns to Marty Tooms, whose remaining appeals are nearly gone. Patch understands that Tooms may die before revealing anything about Callie, yet still says Tooms deserves death for what he did. Sammy also asks whether Patch will paint again, and Patch answers no. Later, Patch finds Charlotte asleep with the television still on, and a news report about a mass shooting makes him feel the full terror of trying to keep another human being alive in a violent, unpredictable world.

Who Appears

  • Patch
    Charlotte’s father; struggles through her first night with him and confronts fear of failing her.
  • Charlotte
    Patch’s grieving daughter; rejects his efforts at comfort and keeps emotional distance.
  • Sammy
    Patch’s friend; advises him on parenting and raises art, Tooms, and New York.
  • Marty Tooms
    Imprisoned abductor discussed as nearing execution, possibly taking answers about Callie with him.
© 2026 SparknotesAI