Saint and Norma leave Jimmy asleep on the couch and walk through the decorated town toward Sammy's gallery. In the shop window, Saint stops at Joseph's new painting and stares at it for a long time, as transfixed as the lost girl it depicts.

Sammy comes to the door dressed for the evening, and Saint immediately presses him for Joseph's whereabouts. When Saint threatens to use the government against him, Sammy rejects the pressure and shifts the argument to the missing girls Joseph has painted, naming Eloise Strike and others. Sammy tells Saint that the girls and the men who took them should come before any hunt for Joseph, and although he says he does not know where Joseph is, Saint admits that if he did, she should be the last person told.

After the confrontation, Saint follows Norma to St. Raphael's. She pauses at Ivy Macauley's grave, then goes inside the cold church, lights a candle, and sits beside her grandmother on the front bench.

In the church, Saint admits she feels as desperate as she did the last time she prayed there and says she hears only silence. Norma answers that evil may be loud, but silence is not weakness, which allows Saint to surrender to what she truly wants. Saint prays that she will not catch Joseph Macauley, then opens her eyes and tells Norma that she is pregnant.