On her birthday, Eve reflects that the day has already been disappointing. Nate rejected her that morning, her stocking ripped, and Addie called her "ma'am." The only bright spot has been a text from Jay and the promise of a gift from him.

During her free period, Eve returns a rare call from her parents. The conversation is formal and strained, which underscores how distant they have become after years of limited contact despite once being close.

Eve's parents call to wish her a happy birthday and ask about her plans, and Eve says Nate is taking her out to dinner. When Eve's mother asks if there is any "news," Eve understands that she means pregnancy. Eve says there is none, and her mother seems relieved, suggesting lingering disapproval of Eve's marriage to Nate.

The call ends with Eve's parents inviting her to visit New Jersey for Christmas. Eve gives a noncommittal answer because she does not want to face their judgment. After the conversation, Eve is left thinking about the biggest truth she has never said to them: they were right, and she should never have married Nate.