While Lucy is sitting with Emmett, Keaton unexpectedly walks up and asks to talk. Lucy is immediately wary because he is Savvy’s brother, but Keaton insists he only wants a conversation. As he sits down and drinks, Lucy is struck again by how much he looks like Savvy, which adds to her unease.

Keaton first circles around the subject by asking about Ben Owens and whether Ben seems to be on Lucy’s side. Lucy deflects his questions with sarcasm, and the exchange stays tense, though Emmett occasionally interrupts and softens the mood. Beneath the banter, Keaton is clearly trying to figure out whether Lucy is still being treated as the obvious killer.

Keaton then admits he has been rethinking what happened after learning more about Matt. He says he did not know Matt was violent, and he also did not know Matt left home that night or that Nina was with him. Because Matt and Nina never told Keaton or anyone else that they were out that night, Keaton now finds their silence suspicious.

When Keaton quietly asks whether Lucy really does not remember that night, an intrusive line from Savvy’s voice cuts through Lucy’s thoughts, showing how disturbing and fragmented Lucy’s memory still is. Emmett says he never believed Lucy was lying, which surprises Lucy. Keaton does not fully apologize, but he effectively concedes that Lucy may be telling the truth and that Matt and Nina’s hidden movements on the night of Savvy’s death need closer scrutiny.