Cover of Listen for the Lie

Listen for the Lie

by Amy Tintera


Genre
Mystery, Thriller, Crime
Year
2024
Pages
317
Contents

Lucy: Five Years Ago — 2

Overview

This flashback reveals the origin of Savvy’s idea that Matt should die and shows that Savvy seriously offered to help Lucy kill her abusive husband. The scene confirms how extreme Matt’s violence was, while connecting Lucy’s present-day haunting thoughts to a real conversation they once had. It deepens both Lucy’s trauma and the story’s larger question of how far desperation and loyalty may have pushed them.

Summary

In a flashback from five years earlier, Lucy jokes with Savvy about killing Lucy’s husband, Matt, suggesting absurd methods and laughing as if the conversation is only dark humor. Lucy assumes Savvy is joking too, but Savvy’s serious expression makes Lucy realize that Savvy means it.

Savvy argues that Matt deserves to die because she has repeatedly seen bruises on Lucy and knows the abuse is worse than Lucy admits aloud. Lucy silently confirms that Savvy is right and remembers some of Matt’s most brutal violence, including choking Lucy until she blacked out and dragging Lucy by the hair before slamming Lucy’s head into the floor.

When Lucy says she cannot kill anyone, Savvy interrupts to make the plan collective, insisting it would be we, not Lucy alone. Lucy tries to defuse the moment with nervous humor about Savvy being an extreme best friend, but Savvy stays committed and directly asks whether they are going to kill Matt, ending the scene with the threat suddenly feeling real.

Who Appears

  • Lucy
    Abused wife who jokes about killing Matt, then confronts Savvy’s serious offer.
  • Savvy
    Lucy’s best friend; insists Matt deserves to die and offers to help kill him.
  • Matt
    Lucy’s violently abusive husband, described through Lucy’s memories of assault.
© 2026 SparknotesAI