Never Lie
by Freida McFadden
Contents
Chapter 43
Overview
Ethan discovers Dr. Hale’s hidden tape room and reacts with unusual intensity when he learns Tricia has been listening to the recordings. His anger, physical grip, and insistence that she stop suggest he has a deeper personal reason for wanting the tapes left alone. After he leaves to seek help, Tricia realizes she must risk returning to Hale’s office to replace the tapes she took before the police can see they were moved.
Summary
After the hidden bookcase swings open, Ethan immediately focuses on the secret room despite Tricia’s attempt to minimize it as a closet. He enters, turns on the light, and discovers shelves filled with recorded patient interviews. Tricia realizes she cannot plausibly pretend ignorance and admits she found the room the day before.
Ethan presses Tricia about whether she has listened to the tapes. Tricia lies at first, then partially admits to hearing only a few, while internally acknowledging she has listened to many more and removed tapes from the room. Ethan’s anger becomes more visible and unsettling, and he orders Tricia not to listen to any more recordings.
As Ethan studies her, Tricia reflects on how little she truly knows about her husband despite their marriage and her pregnancy. His secrecy about his past now feels more disturbing, and she thinks their future together cannot survive hidden truths. The moment deepens her suspicion that Ethan is concealing something important.
Ethan closes the hidden-room door and says he is leaving to get help. Before going, he grabs Tricia’s arm hard enough to frighten her and repeats that she must stay out of the room. He claims the tapes are private patient information and should go to the police, but Tricia senses that this explanation is not the real reason he wants the recordings untouched.
When Ethan asks how she opened the room, Tricia explains that pulling on The Shining triggered the latch. He accepts the answer, puts on his beanie, and leaves the house. Once he is gone, Tricia decides that if Ethan really involves the police, she could be accused of tampering with evidence unless she returns the tapes she removed, which means going back into Dr. Hale’s office.
Who Appears
- TriciaNarrator who is caught hiding the secret tape room and decides to return removed recordings.
- EthanTricia’s husband; discovers the hidden room, reacts angrily, and forbids her from listening to the tapes.