28. Another Option
Contains spoilersOverview
Diplomacy falters when Azir seals its Oathgate and Queen Fen rejects Dalinar’s coalition. Bridge Four finds Oathbringer, which Dalinar returns to Ialai, prompting a sharp clash with Amaram. A searching debate with Taravangian on justice precedes a breakthrough: the Stormfather can share visions, giving Dalinar a new way to meet monarchs.
Summary
Dalinar presses his coalition efforts as Teshav reads Azir’s final refusal: their Oathgate will be sealed and destroyed. He turns to Thaylenah, but while waiting he restlessly inspects Urithiru’s strange ventilation tunnels, mindful of Shallan’s report of a lurking killer. Queen Fen responds with a firm “no,” citing repeated Everstorms and the risk of admitting an Alethi force into her city.
Frustrated, Dalinar is summoned by Bridge Four to the site of Sadeas’s death. Leyten and Peet reveal a gouge on the wall and a sunk hilt between planters: Oathbringer. Dalinar retrieves the Blade, hearing a muted, pained echo from its dead spren; the Stormfather says it “remembers” Dalinar’s oath and surrender of it, hating him less than others. Dalinar decides the killer must have dropped it from a window and takes the weapon to Ialai.
In Ialai’s rooms—with Amaram present—Dalinar returns Oathbringer, denying responsibility for Sadeas’s murder. Amaram defends his own past killings as necessary pragmatism and brands Dalinar a hypocrite who now enjoys the luxury of morality. Dalinar vows to see Amaram judged after the crisis, then withdraws, stung by the accusation.
In his chambers, beside Navani’s heating fabrial, Dalinar and Taravangian debate how a king knows what is right. Dalinar quotes Nohadon’s parable of four suspected murderers: Taravangian would execute all to prevent further harm, while Dalinar recoils from harming an innocent. They note Nohadon’s recorded compromise—imprisoning all four—as an imperfect “other option.” Afterward, the Stormfather asserts Dalinar is not a hypocrite; Dalinar replies that hypocrisy can mark a person in the midst of change.
Seeking guidance, Dalinar requests to revisit a vision. The Stormfather reveals he can show visions to others and allow Dalinar to join them remotely, even across distances during a highstorm. Recognizing a solution to his diplomatic impasse, Dalinar resolves to use shared visions to meet and persuade the other monarchs—beginning with Queen Fen.
Who Appears
- Dalinar Kholin
Bondsmith; rebuffed by Azir and Fen, recovers Oathbringer, returns it to Ialai, confronts Amaram, debates justice with Taravangian, then plans diplomacy via shared visions.
- Taravangian
Kharbranth/Jah Keved king; questions morality, argues for harsh pragmatism, yet empathetic; prompts Dalinar’s insight about using visions to reach monarchs.
- Stormfather
Ancient spren; explains Oathbringer’s muted screams and reveals visions can be shown to others, enabling Dalinar’s new diplomatic plan.
- Meridas Amaram
Ialai’s regent; defends past murders, calls Dalinar a hypocrite; vows practical Shardbearers over ideals.
- Queen Fen
Thaylenah’s queen via spanreed; exhausted by Everstorms and flatly refuses alliance or Oathgate access.
- Ialai Sadeas
Receives Oathbringer from Dalinar; icy and calculating, with Amaram at her side.
- Teshav
Scribe who reads Azir’s rejection and manages spanreed exchange with Queen Fen.
- Leyten
Bridge Four scout; notices wall gouge leading to discovery of Oathbringer.
- Lyn
Messenger who summons Dalinar to Bridge Four’s discovery.
- Peet
Bridge Four member who first spotted the oddity at the wall.
- Navani Kholin
Advises Dalinar; researches tower mysteries; heating fabrial warms his rooms.