Chapter 9

Contains spoilers

Overview

Sheriff Hudson erupts after a TV report reveals DNA linking Ryan Stevens to the Kelly Summers case before the sheriff’s office received the official report. After confirming the leak came from the lab, Hudson orders the entire Summers investigation reopened and reflects on past irregularities and Stevens’s misconduct. Facing mounting media pressure and potential fallout on Stevens’s past cases, Hudson decides to confront Stevens before making a public statement.

Summary

Sheriff Hudson berates his assembled deputies over the DNA leak tying Ryan Stevens to the Kelly Summers homicide, brandishing the lab results that matched a news segment aired the previous night. He underscores the breach of protocol and the media frenzy forming outside the station, pointing to news vans lined up at the front.

When Deputy Lane and Lieutenant Nagel explain that CODIS results arrived after the broadcast, Hudson checks the timestamp and concedes the leak originated from the lab. Deciding a blame hunt would look bad, he reins in his anger and pivots to crisis management.

Hudson orders the Summers case fully reopened, demanding every piece of evidence, statement, report, and transcript be pulled and reviewed. He acknowledges most of his team were not present when the original investigation occurred and tasks everyone to get up to speed immediately.

Alone, Hudson questions what Stevens did and reflects that the original case always felt too easy, with a hasty trial in which Sarah Morgan defended her husband, Adam Morgan, without the prosecution challenging the conflict of interest. He recalls Stevens keeping him at arm’s length under a pretext of conflict due to Hudson’s friendship with Scott Summers, Kelly’s husband and the then–chief deputy, and notes Scott left town after the trial.

Hudson considers the overwhelming work ahead and the broader implications: once the media and lawyers react, hundreds of investigations bearing Stevens’s signature could face appeal. The weight of reinterviewing witnesses and reconstructing a 12-year-old case adds to his anxiety.

When his admin, Marcy, alerts him that reporters demand a statement, Hudson starts toward the lobby but diverts. He decides he must speak to Stevens first, indicating an urgent, personal confrontation before addressing the public.

Who Appears

  • Sheriff Hudson
    current sheriff; leads the department’s response to the DNA leak, orders the Summers case reopened, plans to confront Ryan Stevens.
  • Chief Deputy Olson
    Hudson’s second-in-command; present and supportive but silent during the outburst.
  • Deputy Lane
    rookie deputy; points out the lab leak based on delivery timestamps.
  • Lieutenant Nagel
    senior officer; corroborates the timing and supports Lane’s conclusion.
  • Marcy
    Hudson’s administrative assistant; informs Hudson about reporters demanding a statement.
  • Ryan Stevens
    former sheriff; not present in the scene but central to the reveal as the DNA match in the Kelly Summers case and target of Hudson’s planned confrontation.
  • Kelly Summers
    murder victim; case is ordered reopened.
  • Adam Morgan
    convicted of Kelly’s murder; referenced regarding a fast trial and conflict concerns.
  • Sarah Morgan
    Adam’s wife and former defense attorney; referenced for having defended Adam in the original trial.
  • Scott Summers
    Kelly’s husband and former chief deputy; referenced as having left town after the trial.
© 2025 SparknotesAI