Chapter 12

Contains spoilers

Overview

Sarah Morgan arrives at the Morgan Foundation amid a media swarm and delivers a forceful public statement blaming corruption by former sheriff Ryan Stevens for Adam Morgan’s wrongful conviction. Pressed about Adam’s mother Eleanor Rumple’s threats to sue and her criticism of Sarah, Sarah pointedly rebuts and positions herself as pursuing justice. Inside, Sarah accepts help from Alejandro, hints at a temporary job for him, and instructs Anne to prepare a motion to reopen Adam’s case. Sheriff Hudson then calls to inform Sarah that Ryan Stevens attempted suicide and is in critical condition; Sarah states Ryan is no longer her client and ends the call.

Summary

Sarah Morgan reaches the Morgan Foundation office and is immediately surrounded by reporters. After Alejandro intervenes to create space, Sarah delivers a prepared statement: she recounts defending her husband Adam twelve years ago in the Kelly Summers murder case, asserts Adam’s innocence, and condemns the Prince William County Sheriff’s Office for concealing the identity of a third DNA contributor. She accuses former sheriff Ryan Stevens of violating his oath, implies corruption through his affair with Kelly, and calls the result “murder,” vowing to pursue justice if the legal system cannot.

As Sarah and Alejandro move toward the building, a reporter asks about a new statement by Adam’s mother, Eleanor Rumple, who plans to sue the sheriff’s office and potentially file a wrongful death suit, and who has accused Sarah of mishandling Adam’s case. Sarah refuses to endorse Eleanor directly, saying she supports justice. She then pointedly undermines Eleanor’s claims by referencing Eleanor’s grief, age, and faulty memory, and reiterates that withheld evidence deprived Sarah of the ability to fully defend Adam.

Inside the lobby, Sarah thanks Alejandro for his help. He notes she is giving him a second chance, and he offers to listen if she wants to talk. Sarah deflects, checks on his foundation-provided apartment and clothing, and learns he is struggling to find work due to a felony record. She proposes a temporary, legal job and passes him an address for Saturday at seven. Anne arrives, confirms the media presence, and Roger the security guard promises to keep reporters out.

Anne asks whether the new DNA evidence means Adam was innocent and whether Stevens killed Kelly. Sarah says Adam was always innocent to her but provides no conclusion about Stevens. She reflects on the inconvenient timing with her divorce from Bob Miller and briefly wonders if Bob leaked the DNA story to manipulate her, but dismisses the thought.

In the elevator, Anne asks about legal next steps. Sarah decides they must proactively file a motion to reopen Adam’s case and directs Anne to assign associates and contact allies in Washington, DC, to accelerate court action. When an unknown call comes in, Sarah exits and answers.

Sheriff Hudson informs Sarah that, separate from the now-open investigation into Kelly Summers, Ryan Stevens attempted suicide about an hour earlier and is in critical condition at UVA. Sarah replies that Ryan is no longer her client, thanks Hudson for the call, and hangs up.

Who Appears

  • Sarah Morgan
    attorney, head of the Morgan Foundation; gives a public statement attacking the original investigation, rebuts Eleanor Rumple, assigns a motion to reopen Adam’s case, and acknowledges Ryan Stevens is no longer her client.
  • Alejandro
    foundation beneficiary with a felony record; protects Sarah from reporters, discusses his second chance, and accepts a temporary job meeting set for Saturday.
  • Anne
    Sarah’s colleague at the Morgan Foundation; supports Sarah, raises legal questions, and is tasked with preparing the motion and outreach to DC contacts.
  • Roger
    building security guard; helps keep reporters out and escorts Alejandro through the back entrance.
  • Reporters/Media
    press corps outside the Foundation; prompt Sarah’s statement and question her about Eleanor Rumple’s comments.
  • Eleanor Rumple
    Adam’s mother; discussed via her public statement threatening lawsuits and alleging Sarah mishandled Adam’s case.
  • Sheriff Hudson
    current sheriff; calls Sarah to notify her that Ryan Stevens attempted suicide and that the Summers case is now an open investigation.
  • Ryan Stevens
    former sheriff; offstage but central, recently linked by DNA to the Summers case and reported to be in critical condition after a suicide attempt.
  • Adam Morgan
    Sarah’s late husband; referenced as wrongfully convicted in the Summers case.
  • Kelly Summers
    murder victim; central to Sarah’s statement about concealed DNA evidence and corruption.
© 2025 SparknotesAI