77. The Proper Legality

Contains spoilers

Overview

In a flashback, Venli sneaks through Kholinar to retrieve hidden gemstones but learns Ulim’s agent, Axindweth, has fled. Caught by guards, she is claimed by Nale, who reveals Heralds are present, alleges Gavilar’s betrayal, and points her to a Shin slave bearing Jezrien’s Blade. Ulim leverages this to push Venli into initiating conflict, so the listeners will accept forms of power.

Summary

Seven and a half years earlier, Venli infiltrates forbidden halls in Kholinar to collect gemstones Ulim says were hidden by his agent, Axindweth. Ulim admits he has lost contact with her. In a privy, Venli finds a coded note revealing Axindweth was discovered and has fled, leaving no gemstones. Ulim erupts in agitation, then abandons Venli, who is soon caught by a human guard and taken to a bearded officer.

At the guard post, the officer decides to hold Venli until after the treaty signing. Ulim returns in panic, claiming multiple Heralds are in the palace. An imposing man—Nale—arrives, presents a seal of deputation, and legally requisitions Venli into his custody. He intimidates Ulim and questions Venli about returned Voidspren.

Venli evades, reflecting blame back on Nale. He rants about Gavilar’s forbidden designs and a treaty clause allowing legal preemption with proof of conspiracy. Nale instructs Venli to buy a Shin slave in the market who bears Jezrien’s Blade and is highly trained, asserting this will provide the grounds she needs. He then pardons Venli under code provision eighty-seven and departs.

Afterward, Ulim praises Venli’s manipulation of Nale and fixates on the opportunity. Though Venli protests starting a war, Ulim reenters her gemheart and reframes it as a necessary preemptive act: proof of human betrayal will drive the listeners to desperation and acceptance of forms of power.

Torn but craving strength, Venli accepts the plan. Attuning Destruction, she resolves to act, setting the course toward provoking conflict to save—and elevate—her people.

Who Appears

  • Venli
    Listener scholar; caught sneaking in Kholinar, questioned by Nale, and decides to ignite war to force forms of power.
  • Ulim
    Manipulative Voidspren; reports Axindweth’s exposure, fears Nale, bonds Venli again, and urges a preemptive strike.
  • Nale
    Emotionless Herald; legally claims Venli, alleges Gavilar’s betrayal, directs her to a Shin with Jezrien’s Blade, then pardons her.
  • Bearded guard officer
    Older Alethi soldier who detains Venli until the feast to avoid incidents.
  • Human guard
    Patrolling soldier who arrests Venli and delivers her to the guard post.
  • Scribe woman
    Authenticates Nale’s deputation via spanreed, enabling him to take custody of Venli.
  • Axindweth
    Ulim’s agent in Kholinar; discovered and fled, leaving only a coded message.
© 2025 SparknotesAI