17. A Proposal

Contains spoilers

Overview

The Mink rejects an Alethkar offensive and urges a decisive campaign in Emul to consolidate Makabak, aligning strategy with Dalinar’s private doubts about Taravangian. Jasnah advances kingdom-wide emancipation. Wit brings Heralds Ash and Taln, who confirm the Oathpact is broken, prompting plans to later approach the Shin for Bondsmith lore.

Summary

An epigraph from Navani notes a rare, light metal the Fused use that resists Shardblades and interferes with Radiant powers. In Urithiru, Shallan and Dalinar combine Lightweaving and Bondsmith Connection to project a living map of Roshar for the Mink, who examines coalition and singer deployments on both fronts.

Reviewing Emul/Makabak and the Alethkar–Jah Keved border, the Mink quickly infers Dalinar’s distrust of Taravangian and concludes an Alethkar offensive would be a costly mistake. He advises a decisive push in Emul, where the enemy is landlocked and supply-strained, to consolidate Makabak and achieve a morale-boosting victory.

After the Mink departs to study detailed reports, Dalinar confides his fear of an unwinnable war. Wit insists Odium will not compromise. Jasnah argues for emancipating all slaves, including ardents, despite Dalinar’s concerns about upheaval; she intends to refine the proposal with highprince feedback and proceed.

Wit returns with Heralds Shalash (Ash) and Talenelat (Taln). Ash states the Oathpact is broken—Jezrien was killed permanently—and that she knows little of Bondsmith mechanics, which were Ishar’s domain. Jasnah and Dalinar discuss the need to stabilize Makabak, then approach the Shin for knowledge gained from centuries with Honorblades.

Dalinar accepts the logic: prepare a major offensive in Emul, strengthen the coalition, and—once secure—seek the Shin to learn more about Bondsmith powers and possible paths to sealing the enemy. Jasnah signals she will personally attend the Emul campaign if launched.

Who Appears

  • The Mink
    Herdazian general; analyzes the Radiant map and urges an Emul offensive over a risky push into Alethkar.
  • Dalinar Kholin
    Bondsmith and coalition commander; yearns to retake Alethkar but accepts Emul-first strategy and seeks Bondsmith knowledge.
  • Jasnah Kholin
    Queen of Alethkar; backs Emul strategy, proposes freeing all slaves (including ardents), and plans to attend the campaign.
  • Navani Kholin
    Scholar-queen and POV; observes the planning, hosts discussions, and weighs the implications of strategy and emancipation.
  • Wit
    Queen’s Wit; asserts Odium will not compromise and brings Heralds Ash and Taln to inform strategy.
  • Shallan Davar
    Lightweaver; helps project the interactive map with Dalinar and escorts the Mink to review detailed reports.
  • Shalash (Ash)
    Herald; confirms the Oathpact is broken, notes Ishar’s expertise, and indicates the Shin hold relevant knowledge.
  • Talenelat (Taln)
    Herald; present but incoherent, reinforcing the Heralds’ broken state during the briefing.
  • Adolin Kholin
    Prince; escorts the Mink to archives for deeper strategic review.
© 2025 SparknotesAI