Chapter 57

Contains spoilers

Overview

Scarlett returns from Amsterdam centered and eager for championship season, keeps a light course load, and continues therapy for perspective. Pen reveals that Theo abruptly ended their relationship and wonders if breaking up with Lukas was a mistake. To protect Pen, Scarlett downplays her bond with Lukas. Refocusing on performance, she approaches Coach Sima to discuss changes to her training program.

Summary

In winter quarter, Scarlett keeps a light academic load to accommodate an intense competition stretch. During a check-in with therapist Sam, Scarlett acknowledges not medaling in Amsterdam but frames it as motivation, affirming she is ready and excited for the season ahead.

Later in the locker room, Pen apologizes for asking Scarlett to leave the party and discloses that Theo has broken up with her. Pen describes his reasons and is visibly hurt, noting Lukas reacted kindly but distantly when she told him. Scarlett gently suggests Pen and Lukas may have bonded through trauma, prompting Pen to defend the past relationship.

Pen makes a thoughtless remark contrasting trauma bonding with sexual compatibility, then quickly apologizes. She wonders if breaking up with Lukas was a mistake and asks if Scarlett’s relationship with him is mostly sex. To spare Pen’s feelings, Scarlett admits they are not officially dating and withholds the depth of her connection with Lukas, while reassuring Pen that Theo’s decision is his loss.

Scarlett supports Pen on the way to dryland training, then steps away to focus on her goals. She seeks out Coach Sima and requests a discussion about changing her training program, signaling a renewed commitment to optimizing her performance for the coming championships.

Who Appears

  • Scarlett
    Protagonist; balances light coursework, continues therapy, supports Pen, downplays her bond with Lukas, and seeks training adjustments from Coach Sima.
  • Pen
    Friend reeling after Theo dumps her; questions past with Lukas and finds relief when Scarlett says they aren’t officially dating.
  • Sam
    Therapist who helps Scarlett contextualize Amsterdam and refocus on the upcoming season.
  • Coach Sima
    Diving coach whom Scarlett approaches to discuss modifying her training program.
  • Theo (Hot Teacher)
    Pen’s boyfriend who abruptly ends the relationship, triggering Pen’s heartbreak and doubts.
  • Lukas
    Off-page; responds distantly to Pen’s news and remains the unspoken center of shifting relationship tensions.
© 2025 SparknotesAI