Chapter 44

Contains spoilers

Overview

November’s grind brings small wins that rebuild Scarlett’s confidence: podium finishes and a strong inward. She learns Lukas is interviewing for med school and likely to defer, while Pen’s romance with Theo deepens. Dr. Carlsen offers a recommendation letter. Before Thanksgiving, Scarlett and Lukas reconnect, agree to present at a conference, and part with a charged, private moment ahead of Winter Nationals.

Summary

November opens in a rush of meets, travel, and classes. With Victoria back and chirping from the deck, Scarlett keeps producing serviceable inward dives, guided by Sam’s “done is better than perfect” framing. At a small away meet in Pullman, Pen wins platform, Scarlett places third, and their synchro pairs podium, briefly restoring Scarlett’s joy in competition. Lukas texts congratulations after ten silent days, a tender spark that underscores his absence.

Back at Avery, seagulls shut down the pool, and strength training replaces practice. Scarlett overhears that Lukas returned from Europe for a Seattle med school interview and plans to defer, news she realizes he never shared. Pen teases Scarlett about missing him and, over lunch, reveals her own relationship with Theo is warming—he’s invited her to spend Thanksgiving together—while describing Lukas as emotionally reserved.

The team travels to Minnesota, where Scarlett earns 7/7/7.5 on an inward and edges closer to the twins in synchro. After a German makeup exam, she spars academically with Dr. Carlsen, who ultimately offers a med school recommendation, citing her research with Dr. Smith. Maryam departs for Florida, leaving a joking “gold medal” and texts.

Choosing rest over obsessive training, Scarlett books Thanksgiving in St. Louis after Sam’s nudge. On the last practice day, she notices Lukas poolside with Pen, swallows her nerves, and nails her best inward yet. Outside, Lukas waits for her; they discuss Olive’s email about a bio conference and agree to present together—good for applications, and, he admits, fun with her. They nearly make other plans, trade small talk about Thanksgiving and his “troll” good-luck stamp, and he tucks a lock of her hair back, a fleeting, intimate touch.

They part with Lukas’s “keep in touch, if you want,” and Scarlett leaves for the airport, carrying the promise of their collaboration and the ache of their secrecy, with Winter Nationals looming.

Who Appears

  • Scarlett
    Protagonist; podiums at two meets, improves her inward dive, secures a rec letter, and shares a charged goodbye with Lukas.
  • Lukas
    Scarlett’s secret partner; texts congrats, interviews for med school with plans to defer, proposes conference presentation, and shares a brief intimate moment.
  • Pen
    Teammate and Lukas’s ex; wins platform, teases Scarlett, remains close to Lukas, and considers spending Thanksgiving with Theo.
  • Coach Sima
    Diving coach; emphasizes progress over perfection, cancels water practice due to seagulls, praises Scarlett’s improved inward.
  • Sam
    Therapist; reinforces “done is better than perfect,” guiding Scarlett’s approach to dives and holiday balance.
  • Dr. Adam Carlsen
    Professor; debates grading with Scarlett and offers a med school recommendation based on her strong performance and research.
  • Victoria
    Friend with cast off; offers blunt, affectionate critiques and boosts team morale.
  • Maryam
    Roommate; jokes about Scarlett’s immune system, leaves for Florida, and pranks with a fake gold medal.
  • Bella
    Twin diver; synchro competitor whose back issues affect results.
  • Bree
    Twin diver; asks Pen about missing Lukas and competes alongside Bella.
  • Monroe
    Swimmer; asks about Lukas’s whereabouts, prompting reveal of his med school interview.
  • Theo
    Pen’s new partner; invites her to spend Thanksgiving together, signaling a deepening relationship.
© 2025 SparknotesAI