Chapter 5

Contains spoilers

Overview

Scarlett assesses her classes, struggles with German, and confronts her platform nerves, prompting Coach Sima to demand she stop swapping to “safe” dives. At the Simas’ cookout, she encounters Lukas and deflects Mrs. Sima’s probing questions. A tipsy Pen confirms her breakup with Lukas, then shocks both by proposing Scarlett and Lukas sleep together. This upends team dynamics and raises personal stakes for all three.

Summary

Scarlett takes stock of her coursework, finding English and psychology manageable, computational biology easy, and German disastrous. On a call, her mother Barb, an orthopedic surgeon, reinforces Scarlett’s medical ambitions. During preseason training, Scarlett’s fear at ten meters resurfaces; she performs a controlled headstand and nails an unassigned, familiar “emotional support” dive instead of the called dive.

Coach Sima praises the execution as NCAA-caliber but reprimands Scarlett for changing dives, insisting the problem is in her head and urging her to commit. He sends the team to his annual cookout. Scarlett arrives with Victoria and literally runs into Lukas Blomqvist. While Mrs. Sima quizzes Lukas about the Swedish Open, his world title, and the Olympics—and needles Pen’s past mistakes—Lukas coolly defends Pen’s injury recovery. Seeing his discomfort, Scarlett lies that Pen is looking for him to give him an exit.

Over dinner and Coach Sima’s home brew, team dynamics swirl: the synchronized-twin couples charm and bemuse, and Pen pulls Scarlett aside to the backyard swings. Tipsy and needing quiet, Pen and Scarlett joke about the twins, then Pen admits she and Lukas have broken up. Pen decides Lukas should drive her home and texts him.

Lukas approaches and offers to take Pen home. As the three converge, Pen, buoyed by alcohol and impulse, abruptly proposes that Scarlett and Lukas should have sex, jolting the moment and reframing their newly altered relationships.

Who Appears

  • Scarlett (Vandy)
    Protagonist diver; struggles with German, swaps to a safe dive on platform; reprimanded by Coach; navigates cookout dynamics.
  • Penelope Ross
    Team captain; tipsy but sociable; confirms breakup with Lukas and impulsively suggests Scarlett and Lukas should have sex.
  • Lukas Blomqvist
    Elite swimmer and Olympian; reserved; endures Mrs. Sima’s questioning, defends Pen, offers to drive her home post-breakup.
  • Coach Sima
    Diving coach; praises Scarlett’s form but orders her to stop changing dives; hosts the team cookout.
  • Mrs. Sima
    Coach’s wife; probes Lukas about competitions and needles Pen’s past mistakes, prompting Scarlett’s timely intervention.
  • Barb
    Scarlett’s mother; accomplished orthopedic surgeon whose dedication inspires Scarlett’s medical ambitions.
  • Victoria
    Teammate and Pen’s synchro partner; drives Scarlett to the cookout and keeps a low profile.
  • Bree
    Diving twin; practices synchronized dives; appears at the cookout with her twin partner.
  • Bella
    Diving twin; practices synchronized dives; appears at the cookout with her twin partner.
© 2025 SparknotesAI