The Splendid and the Vile
by Erik Larson
Contents
Chapter 34: Ol’ Man River
Overview
Churchill works to justify the destroyers-for-bases agreement at a moment when Britain’s shipping losses, factory disruptions, and fear of invasion make American support increasingly vital. In Parliament he reframes the deal as a strategic knitting-together of Britain and the United States and, in the same speech, delivers his famous tribute to the RAF as “the few.” The chapter also shows the strain on wartime production through Beaverbrook’s resistance to a prayer-day shutdown and contrasts high politics with Colville’s distracted, morally uneasy romance with Audrey Paget.
Summary
With Britain losing merchant ships and facing heavier Luftwaffe attacks on airfields and aircraft factories, Winston Churchill sees that the destroyers-for-bases agreement with the United States cannot be allowed to fail. Because American neutrality law prevents Franklin Roosevelt from presenting the destroyers as a simple gift, Churchill reluctantly accepts a transactional framing, but he decides to present the arrangement to Parliament in his own way. As invasion fears spread across Britain, Churchill spends August 19 and 20 drafting a major speech on the war situation, while John Colville observes how Churchill patiently stores and reuses lines from poetry and scripture. Churchill’s concentration is briefly broken by construction noise near the Cabinet War Rooms, prompting him to order Colville to stop it.
At the same time, Lord Beaverbrook continues struggling to keep aircraft and munitions production running. Shipping losses, bombing, worker absences, and air-raid alarms are already slowing output, and the Church of England’s proposal for a National Day of Prayer threatens another interruption. Churchill refuses to shut the factories entirely but agrees workers should have time on Sunday, September 8, to attend church. Beaverbrook, annoyed at any further disruption, suggests that clergy visit the factories instead, so workers can pray without leaving their posts.
On the afternoon of August 20, Churchill delivers his speech to a sluggish House of Commons. He avoids discussing the destroyers directly and instead describes the base leases as a generous British act meant to ease American security concerns, insisting that British sovereignty is not being surrendered. Churchill emphasizes that the agreement matters because it binds Britain and the United States more closely together, comparing the growing connection between the two English-speaking democracies to the unstoppable Mississippi River. In the same speech, while praising the Royal Air Force, Churchill utters the line later immortalized as his tribute to “the few”: “Never in the field of human conflict was so much owed by so many to so few.”
Churchill leaves pleased with the speech and sings “Ol’ Man River” on the drive back to Downing Street, but Colville judges the address less compelling than Churchill’s best and notes that the House seems most interested in the base-lease portion. Colville’s attention soon shifts from politics to his personal life. That evening he dines with Audrey Paget, whose beauty charms him despite her youth and her family’s ugly fascist and anti-Semitic associations. After dinner, a play, and an unsatisfying nightclub visit, Colville records that the flirtation grows more intense, leaving him both excited and uneasy.
Who Appears
- Winston ChurchillPrime minister who crafts and delivers a speech defending the bases deal and praising the RAF.
- John ColvilleChurchill’s aide; observes the speechmaking process and spends the evening courting Audrey Paget.
- Lord BeaverbrookAircraft production chief, frustrated by raids, disruptions, and the proposed prayer-day interruption.
- Franklin RooseveltU.S. president whose neutrality constraints force the destroyers deal into a quid pro quo form.
- Audrey PagetYoung woman who becomes the focus of Colville’s increasingly intense flirtation.
- Lord QueenboroughAudrey Paget’s father, a Conservative MP noted here for fascist leanings.
- Edith Starr MillerAudrey Paget’s mother, described as anti-Semitic and obsessed with conspiracy theories.
- Herbert UpwardChurch newspaper editor who urges a National Day of Prayer shutdown for munitions workers.
- Ernest BevinLabor minister cited by Beaverbrook as one of the recurring obstacles to production.
- Lord KemsleySunday Times owner who briefly interrupts Colville’s dinner by handing him a large cigar.