Wind and Truth
by Brandon Sanderson
Contents
Chapter 19
Overview
Kaladin and Szeth finally cross into Shinovar, and the landscape’s ordinary soil and plant life reveal how alien the region is compared with the rest of Roshar. The moment hits Szeth with unexpected intensity, exposing both his buried attachment to his homeland and his continued dependence on rigid obedience to control himself. Their arrival also sharpens the contrast between Kaladin’s empathy and Szeth’s harsh, rule-bound worldview as their mission enters Szeth’s home territory.
Summary
As Szeth-son-Honor and Kaladin-son-Lirin fly toward Shinovar, Szeth reflects that he still dresses in white and keeps old routines even though no one now requires it. He clings to these habits because small choices feel easier than deciding his true duty to his people. As they near the Misted Mountains by a southern pass, avoiding the hostile northern border, Szeth briefly enjoys the silence from the accusing voices that haunt him.
Crossing the pass, Szeth sees Shinovar’s first patches of true soil, where the highstorms lose their force and ordinary plant life can grow. The sight overwhelms him. He drops to the ground, kneels in the dirt, and reverently touches a simple weed, moved by returning to a land where feet can stand on soil instead of stone.
Kaladin, unfamiliar with Shinovar’s unmoving plants, studies the weed with curiosity while Syl comments beside him. Szeth’s highspren appears only to him and rebukes his display of emotion as beneath a Skybreaker’s dignity, pushing Szeth back toward composure and obedience. Nightblood also speaks from Szeth’s back, but Kaladin ignores the sword and focuses on Szeth’s state.
When Kaladin hesitates even to step on the weed, Szeth bluntly mocks him for abandoning the spear and becoming a coward. The exchange irritates Kaladin, but Szeth treats his words as simple truth rather than cruelty. They continue through the pass until they reach a vista over Shinovar, where Kaladin sees for the first time a landscape covered entirely in green, ordinary vegetation. For Kaladin, the view is wondrous; for Szeth, it confirms that he has truly come home, though the condemning whispers return with the shadows.
Who Appears
- Szeth-son-HonorReturns to Shinovar, is overwhelmed by its soil and plants, and struggles between emotion and rigid obedience.
- Kaladin-son-LirinTravels with Szeth into Shinovar, marvels at its ordinary plants, and clashes with Szeth’s blunt provocations.
- SylKaladin’s spren; examines Shinovar’s strange plants and lightly comments on the unfamiliar environment.
- Szeth’s highsprenRebukes Szeth’s sentimentality and urges him to maintain Skybreaker dignity and composure.
- NightbloodSpeaks from Szeth’s back, complaining humorously about being ignored during the journey.