Chapter 5
Contains spoilersOverview
Alice reads Charlie Florek’s detailed note outlining extensive safety and comfort upgrades he made to the Kalinski cottage and his promise to look after Alice and Nan. Over dinner and cleanup, Alice and Nan reminisce, discuss household memories, and decide to refresh the cottage with new sewn items, planning to find a sewing machine and fabric in town. Later, Alice swims at sunset, reflects on her recent breakup and overwork, and watches neighboring kids play on the water until a loud yellow boat approaches the dock, evoking her past summers.
Summary
Alice finds a handwritten letter from Charlie Florek listing the accessibility modifications he completed for Nan: removing rugs, rearranging furniture, adding bathroom grab bars and anti-slip strips, installing a raised toilet seat and night-lights, and reorganizing the kitchen. He notes the boat is in and fueled, leaves homemade pierogi, and says John covered costs. On the back, he details upcoming cottage maintenance for John (steps, railing, brush cutting, dock re-staining) and adds a final assurance that he promised John he would take care of Alice and Nan.
Alice reacts with skepticism at Charlie’s confidence while Nan is grateful, calling him a “guardian angel.” That evening, they eat the pierogi, which Alice finds excellent. In the kitchen, Nan points out she sewed the old curtains and reminisces about family visits, including a matchbook-hiding game between Grandpa and John, whose jar of found matchbooks Nan calls “memories.”
Alice reassures Nan she will make the summer enjoyable and lists the supports she arranged: choir, euchre, hair appointments, physiotherapist, and newspaper delivery. Nan urges Alice to also do something for herself, pushing her beyond mere editing work. Alice tentatively outlines plans to read, swim, and take photos, admitting the unstructured time feels daunting.
They decide on a shared creative project: sewing to refresh the cottage. Remembering past sewing collaborations, they agree to make new kitchen curtains and potentially pillowcases and a tablecloth. Nan proposes acquiring a sewing machine and fabric, suggesting the local Stedmans as a starting point. Alice agrees, unconcerned about John’s opinion.
Tired from the day, Nan goes to bed after their old refrain, “Good things happen at the lake.” In the heat, Alice changes into a swimsuit and heads to the deck and dock, taking in the expansive view of the bay and recalling her teenage summer spent exploring and photographing nature after Nan encouraged her to “go explore.”
Swimming at sunset, Alice reflects on the last six months: a breakup with Trevor, his quick engagement to someone else, and Alice’s reactive overwork that brought professional busyness without fulfillment. She dries off in a Muskoka chair, observes neighboring cottages—including an A-frame and a large white house—and watches two younger siblings swim and play on a floating raft, their joy stirring memories of the teens she once photographed.
As evening quiet returns, a loud motor breaks the calm. A yellow boat rounds the bay and heads directly toward Alice, jolting her with a powerful sense of past and present colliding.
Who Appears
- Alice Everly
protagonist; reads Charlie’s note, plans cottage-sewing projects with Nan, swims, and reflects on her breakup and overwork.
- Nan (Alice’s grandmother)
recovering from a hip injury; appreciates Charlie’s preparations, reminisces, encourages Alice to pursue her own enjoyment, and agrees to sewing projects.
- Charlie Florek
caretaker; not present in person but central via detailed letter, completed accessibility upgrades, left food, and promised John he would look after Alice and Nan.
- John Kalinski
cottage owner; not present but mentioned as funding modifications and assigning Charlie cottage maintenance.
- Trevor
Alice’s ex-boyfriend; only discussed in Alice’s reflections as the cause of recent emotional turmoil and overwork.
- Grandpa (Alice’s grandfather)
deceased; remembered for the matchbook-hiding game with John.
- Joyce
John’s late partner; remembered, associated with the cottage and Nan’s memories.
- Neighbor kids
unnamed siblings at the A-frame; observed swimming and playing on the raft, triggering Alice’s nostalgia.