The Shadow of the Wind
by Carlos Ruiz Zafón
Contents
City of Shadows — Chapter 43
Overview
Daniel attends Nuria Monfort’s funeral at Montjuïc, shaken by grief and by how few truly mourn her, including Isaac’s absence. On the way back, Palacios tries to warn Daniel off the Carax investigation and hints that the violence is escalating beyond control. Palacios relays Nuria’s final words about Penélope, and Daniel realizes the message was meant for Julián Carax, reframing Nuria’s death as tied to Carax’s long-buried past.
Summary
Daniel takes a bus from Paseo de Colón to the Montjuïc cemetery for Nuria Monfort’s burial. He walks through the vast, bleak necropolis, passing near his mother’s grave and feeling the place’s cold silence and anger.
At the graveside, Daniel watches the priest’s rite over a simple pine coffin guarded by gravediggers. He notes who is present and absent: Isaac, the keeper of the Cemetery of Forgotten Books and Nuria’s father, does not attend. Daniel recognizes a neighbor and her husband, sees an unfamiliar woman in gray with flowers, and spots Enrique Palacios—the policeman who recently saved Daniel’s life—standing apart.
Overcome, Daniel cries; the woman in gray quietly offers him a flower. Daniel stays until the mourners disperse, then leaves without managing a proper farewell.
Near the cemetery gates at dusk, Daniel expects to be stranded, but Palacios waits in a black car and insists on driving him back. In the car, Palacios expresses regret about Nuria’s death and urges Daniel to drop the entire matter and forget Carax, warning that it has gone too far.
Daniel rejects Palacios’s concern and orders him to stop, calling the car and Palacios “death.” After Daniel gets out, Palacios reveals that Nuria died in his arms and that her last words seemed like a message: “There are worse prisons than words,” and a request to “let her go,” referring to someone named Penélope. Later, sitting by the port where Daniel once met Laín Coubert, Daniel realizes the message was not for him but for Julián Carax, the man Nuria loved in silence for twenty years.
Who Appears
- Daniel SempereAttends Nuria’s funeral; rebuffs Palacios; interprets Nuria’s last message as meant for Carax.
- Enrique PalaciosPoliceman who drives Daniel home, warns him off Carax, and relays Nuria’s last words.
- Nuria MonfortDeceased; buried this chapter; her final words reference Penélope and “worse prisons than words.”
- Penélope AldayaNamed in Nuria’s final request to “let her go,” linking the message to Carax’s past.
- Julián CaraxImplied recipient of Nuria’s last message; her secret love for him is confirmed by Daniel’s realization.
- Isaac (keeper of the Cemetery of Forgotten Books)Mentioned as absent from his daughter Nuria Monfort’s funeral.
- Unidentified woman in grayMourner at the graveside who offers Daniel a flower as he cries.
- PriestConducts the funeral rite over Nuria Monfort’s coffin.