The Shadow of the Wind
by Carlos Ruiz Zafón
Contents
Nuria Monfort: Remembrance of the Lost — Chapter 3
Overview
The chapter reveals Sophie Carax’s early life in Barcelona and how she became trapped long before her later dependence on Antoni Fortuny. While working as a piano tutor, Sophie is drawn into a brutal, secret affair with the powerful Don Ricardo Aldaya, who leaves her injured and pregnant, then demands an abortion and threatens her life. Seeking protection and denial, Sophie marries Fortuny, but Aldaya’s ominous warning on the wedding day signals the danger is not over.
Summary
Sophie Carax’s past is recounted from years before she became Antoni Fortuny’s “slave.” At nineteen she comes to Barcelona expecting a job that fails to appear, and seeks help from the Benarenses, family friends from Alsace. Monsieur Benarens welcomes her too warmly, and Madame Benarens gives Sophie money and sends her away, leaving Sophie to find work on her own.
Sophie is hired by a music school on Calle Diputación as a private piano tutor for wealthy families. She endures the contempt of many pupils and households, but continues for survival, focusing on the few students who show talent or decency. During this period she meets Antoni Fortuny, a hatter who persistently courts her and repeatedly proposes; Sophie feels friendship and gratitude but not love, yet his devotion eases her loneliness.
Through her favorite student, the gifted young Ana Valls, Sophie is drawn into the Valls household, where she meets Don Ricardo Aldaya, a powerful oligarch newly married for money and alliances. A single encounter convinces Sophie that Aldaya is dangerous, yet also awakens a conflicted, instinctive attraction and fear. Sophie tries to flee future contact by quitting Ana Valls as a pupil, but Aldaya is amused and unbothered.
A week later Aldaya intercepts Sophie outside the music school and silently leads her to an empty apartment where he demands the truth of her desire; Sophie cannot deny she has thought of him. They begin a secret affair that lasts ninety-six days, meeting twice a week for brief, controlled encounters. Sophie is left emotionally shattered, sometimes remaining alone afterward to cry and shake, while still searching on Sundays in Antoni Fortuny’s adoring gaze for a version of herself that feels safe and good.
When Sophie suspects she is pregnant with Aldaya’s child, she clings to Antoni Fortuny’s protection and accepts his promise of marriage. Aldaya confirms her pregnancy, gives her money and an address, and orders her to abort; when Sophie refuses, he beats her and threatens to have her killed if she ever speaks of him or the child. Sophie lies to Fortuny about being assaulted, and Fortuny believes her; on Sophie and Fortuny’s wedding day, a mistakenly delivered funeral wreath terrifies Sophie because she understands Aldaya’s threat is real and ongoing.
Who Appears
- Sophie CaraxYoung piano tutor in Barcelona; abused by Aldaya, becomes pregnant, marries Fortuny for protection.
- Don Ricardo AldayaPowerful oligarch; seduces and brutalizes Sophie, demands an abortion, threatens to kill her.
- Antoni FortunyDevoted hatter who persistently courts Sophie and marries her, unaware of Aldaya’s abuse.
- Ana VallsSophie’s talented favorite pupil; her household brings Sophie into Aldaya’s reach.
- Mr. VallsAna’s father; wealthy manufacturer who hosts Aldaya and values music as social polish.
- Monsieur BenarensFamily acquaintance who welcomes Sophie too warmly, provoking his wife’s rejection of Sophie.
- Madame BenarensMonsieur Benarens’s wife; gives Sophie money and expels her from the household.