Chapter 25

Contains spoilers

Overview

Alice and Hayden share a tender morning after the storm, reaffirming their plan to let Margaret decide the project while navigating new intimacy and looming career choices. After power is restored, Alice fields a tense, ambiguous check-in call from her mother that stirs old anxieties. Later, on the creek with Margaret, Alice helps clean litter as Margaret resumes interviews and admits they are approaching the period of her greatest mistakes, setting up discussion of her famed love story.

Summary

In the storm’s aftermath, Alice and Hayden eat peanut butter–banana sandwiches by candlelight and joke about Cosmo Sinclair. Hayden confides that the job feels strange, as if Margaret is testing him, and reiterates he could walk away; Alice insists they should let Margaret choose how it ends. They hold each other and agree to continue.

Alice wakes on the couch as power returns and sees Hayden quietly tidying before leaving for his rescheduled interview. They exchange a soft goodbye and plans to see each other that night. After maintenance removes the window plywood, Alice recalls their night of closeness that stopped short of sex, and a long working dinner at Rum Room where they flirted and worked with comfortable intimacy.

When Alice charges her phone, she finds numerous missed messages: group chat chatter, notes from Theo angling to reconnect, and multiple urgent messages from her mother. Panicked for Audrey, Alice calls back, only to learn there is no emergency; her mother was concerned about the storm and vaguely asks about Alice’s location and Hayden. The conversation, clipped and indirect, leaves Alice unsettled by the distance and ambiguity, especially at her mother’s use of “we.”

At the next interview session, Alice meets Margaret on the boat prepared with long clothes and a homemade repellant. They ride to a teen hangout spot on the creek where Margaret has them skim trash with nets while they talk. Margaret explains the area is patrolled and littered, and they collect bottles and a lone neon-green rubber clog, bagging unusable trash.

As they work, Margaret asks how Alice feels about the process and then admits she has been dreading this phase because they are nearing “all my greatest mistakes.” Alice notes internally that this refers to Margaret’s highly public love story. Margaret, sounding weary but willing, suggests they proceed while continuing to clean the creek, signaling a transition into the most fraught chapter of her past.

Who Appears

  • Alice
    narrator; deepens intimacy with Hayden, fields a fraught call from her mother, and resumes interviewing while helping Margaret clean litter.
  • Hayden
    Alice’s colleague and romantic partner; expresses suspicion that Margaret is testing him, leaves for his interview, and plans to see Alice later.
  • Margaret Grace Ives
    interview subject; prepares Alice for the boat outing, has them collect creek trash, and acknowledges they are approaching her greatest mistakes.
  • Alice’s mother
    appears via phone; calls repeatedly due to the storm, speaks ambiguously about “we,” and asks after Hayden.
  • Theo
    Alice’s ex; texts attempting to reconnect.
  • Jodi
    Margaret’s assistant; referenced as being on vacation and as the source of the repellant and local patrol info.
  • Maintenance worker
    bearded rental company employee; removes plywood after the storm.
© 2025 SparknotesAI