The Story

Contains spoilers

Overview

Alice reframes the public narrative of the book as a love story and describes cautious steps toward connection between Margaret Ives and Nicollet through letters and time. Alice, Hayden, and Alice's mother regularly visit and help Margaret, while Alice and Hayden's coauthored book becomes a hit amid wild speculation. Alice and Hayden move in together, marry their lives, and welcome a daughter, Laura Grace Anderson-Scott. Inspired by motherhood and Margaret's mosaics, Alice begins writing the full truth of her family story for her daughter.

Summary

Alice contrasts the tabloid version of her and Hayden's project with their own view: at its core, the story is about love. She notes they told the truth "mostly," but acknowledges that Nicollet is a deliberate omission to protect Hayden's mother, who prefers privacy while being open to knowing Margaret as her biological mother.

Alice explains that there is a careful path forward for Margaret and Nicollet, to be walked at their pace. Margaret is slowing down physically, so Alice and Alice's mother visit to tend the garden, and Hayden joins them. They ride the airboat to collect trash and watch Margaret transform broken pieces into mosaics. Alice returns the mosaic Margaret made for her; later it disappears from the mantel, and Margaret says she sent it off with a letter, implying contact with Nicollet.

Their book is a success, igniting message-board speculation. Conspiracy theorists claim Cosmo Sinclair is alive based on Margaret’s voice in the text. Alice counters that Cosmo lives on in memory, specifically through his grandson, linking Cosmo to Hayden via Nicollet.

Alice reveals she is pregnant. Hayden becomes doting and excited, singing to Alice’s belly and obsessing over baby names. As Alice goes into labor, they finally choose a name on the drive to the hospital. Family and friends—Laura, Jodi, Margaret, Cecil, Audrey, Priya, Bianca, Cillian, and Hayden’s brother Louis—pepper them with texts while waiting.

Alice gives birth to Laura Grace Anderson-Scott at 11:53 p.m. on a Tuesday. Overwhelmed by love as Hayden holds their daughter, Alice feels the darkness inside her dissolve and vows to protect the child. In that moment, Alice feels closer than ever to both of her parents.

Reflecting on Margaret’s labyrinth-like path of broken glass around the workshop, Alice draws meaning from turning heartbreak into beauty. She decides that whether her path was chosen or predetermined matters less than embracing it fully.

Four months later, after Laura begins sleeping better, Alice sits down with coffee from Hayden to start writing the comprehensive story she wants her daughter to know. She resolves to include not just headlines but the full truth—the good and bad, the magic and curses—framing it as a love powerful enough to remake the world, and welcoming Laura into a great big beautiful life.

Who Appears

  • Alice Scott
    narrator and coauthor; visits Margaret, returns a mosaic, becomes pregnant, gives birth to Laura, and begins writing her family's full story.
  • Hayden Anderson
    coauthor and Alice’s partner; supports contact boundaries around Nicollet, helps Margaret, becomes an expectant father, and welcomes daughter Laura.
  • Margaret Ives
    subject of the book; physically slowing, continues mosaic art, likely sends Alice’s mosaic with a letter (implying outreach to Nicollet), and awaits updates about Laura’s birth.
  • Nicollet
    Hayden’s mother and Margaret’s biological daughter; prefers privacy from public revelation but is open to knowing Margaret; referenced as the protected omission.
  • Laura Scott
    Alice’s mother; helps tend Margaret’s garden and waits at the hospital during the birth.
  • Laura Grace Anderson-Scott
    Alice and Hayden’s newborn daughter; born at 11:53 p.m. on a Tuesday; namesake of Alice’s mother.
  • Dr. Cecil Willoughby
    Margaret’s longtime confidant and Laura’s husband; sends supportive texts during the birth.
  • Audrey
    friend/contact; texts updates during the birth.
  • Priya
    friend/contact; texts updates during the birth.
  • Bianca
    friend/contact; texts updates during the birth.
  • Cillian
    friend/contact; texts updates during the birth.
  • Louis
    Hayden’s brother; texts updates during the birth.
  • Message board readers
    online commentators; speculate about Cosmo Sinclair’s fate after the book’s release.
  • Cosmo Sinclair
    deceased actor; invoked in speculation and remembered through his grandson.
  • Jodi Willoughby
    Laura and Cecil’s daughter; sends texts during the birth.
© 2025 SparknotesAI