Chapter 12
Contains spoilersOverview
Alice and Margaret leave the workshop and discuss Nina Gill’s two-year “mystery illness,” Margaret’s belief in fate-like, unicursal paths, and why Margaret chose to speak now. Back at the house, Jodi’s role as Margaret’s gatekeeper and household handler is underscored, while Margaret hints at longstanding isolation and a promise to someone now deceased. After a strong prior interview about Gerald and Nina’s aftermath, Margaret abruptly cancels Alice’s next two sessions, unsettling Alice. Alice is invited to a Fish Bowl party by Captain Cecil, then runs into Hayden; they trade guarded admissions about the job and tentatively consider friendship while maintaining competition.
Summary
Alice and Margaret leave the mosaic workshop discussing Nina Gill’s “mystery illness,” with Margaret dismissing tabloidy explanations and noting women have many reasons to disappear. As they walk the unicursal garden path, Margaret muses about removing choice to find peace and hints she uses a fan boat more than a car. When Alice asks why Margaret is speaking now, Margaret reveals she made a promise to someone and they died before she could retract it, refusing to name the person.
Back at the house, Jodi pointedly asserts that no one else is ever inside, and Margaret confirms Jodi handles sales, groceries, and logistics. The scene underscores Margaret’s isolation and dependence on Jodi, while Margaret jokes about her disappearing act and ends the chitchat for a meal.
The narrative then recalls the prior day’s interview notes: Nina’s illness brought weight fluctuation, hair loss, and a Swiss Alps recovery, during which Nina fell in love with her doctor. After the breakup, Gerald reconnected with his sister Gigi, moved Gigi and her baby Ruth to his estate, and kept managing Nina’s career briefly. Public sentiment turned against Nina’s talkie-era films; she retired in 1931. That same year Gerald brought Rosalind, Freddy, and Francine to the House of Ives, along with Gigi and Ruth, while he and Rosalind remained separate and Gerald doted on Ruth, nicknamed Little Princess (LP).
Alice reflects that Margaret is holding back deeper truths despite permitting recording, and resolves to earn trust over time rather than rush. Alice worries Hayden might be progressing faster.
On Saturday morning, Margaret abruptly cancels Alice’s session for both Saturday and Sunday without explanation, heightening Alice’s fear she may be dismissed. Dejected, Alice encounters Captain Cecil in the parking lot; he invites her to Fish Bowl’s annual summer party honoring his December birthday.
At the Little Croissant patio, Alice unexpectedly meets Hayden. When Alice admits Margaret canceled, Hayden refuses to speculate but concedes he’s reasonably certain he will be hired. After a tense exchange, Hayden admits he “can’t give this up,” and Alice agrees she can’t either. Hayden proposes being friends if they can avoid talking about Margaret; Alice declines for the evening due to plans at Fish Bowl and jokes about taking his job, leaving their dynamic competitive but slightly thawed.
Who Appears
- Alice Scott
reporter and narrator; questions Margaret about Nina’s illness and Margaret’s timing; has sessions canceled; receives party invite; spars with Hayden and sets boundaries.
- Margaret Grace Ives
reclusive subject; hints at women’s reasons to disappear, a unicursal-life philosophy, and a broken promise to someone deceased; relies on Jodi; cancels Alice’s weekend sessions.
- Jodi
Margaret’s companion/handler; manages food, groceries, sales; emphasizes their isolation; cedes kitchen tasks to Margaret.
- Nina Gill
actress, discussed; endured a two-year illness with visible aftereffects, fell for her doctor, retired in 1931 after poor reception to talkies.
- Gerald Rupert Ives
discussed; reconnected with sister Gigi, moved family to the House of Ives in 1931, remained estranged from Rosalind, doted on niece Ruth.
- Gigi (Gerald’s sister)
discussed; widowed in England, moved in with Gerald with her infant daughter Ruth.
- Ruth “Little Princess/LP”
discussed; Gigi’s daughter, cherished and spoiled by Gerald.
- Rosalind Goodlett Ives
discussed; moved back in 1931 with Gerald but did not share a room with him.
- Freddy Ives
discussed; adult son, relocated under Gerald’s control.
- Francine Ives
discussed; adult daughter, relocated under Gerald’s control.
- Hayden Anderson
rival researcher; meets Alice at the cafe; admits he can’t give up the job and suggests friendship while maintaining competition.
- Captain Cecil
bar owner; invites Alice to Fish Bowl’s annual summer party honoring his December birthday.
- Theo
Alice’s friend; texting from an Atlanta shoot, tentatively plans to visit for the evening.