Chapter 3
Contains spoilersOverview
Alice woke late with a caffeine-withdrawal headache and sought coffee at a local enclave, where she accidentally swapped drinks with Hayden Anderson and had a brief, tense exchange. As Hayden took a call from Margaret Grace Ives, Alice feared he had been chosen, but soon received a call from Jodi scheduling Alice for a second meeting with Margaret that evening. Alice ended the chapter relieved and hopeful.
Summary
Alice Scott woke at 9:32 a.m. with a severe headache she recognized as caffeine withdrawal. She noted the contrast between Margaret Grace Ives’s marsh-side property and the island’s oceanfront resorts, adding a question about that choice to her prospective interview list. Reflecting on Hayden Anderson’s reverse-structured biography Our Friend Len, she considered finding a structural device for Margaret’s story to strip away myth and reveal personhood, but postponed deeper thought until she had coffee.
Alice dressed and drove to a well-reviewed cafe, Little Croissant, in the Little Crescent Enclave. After ordering, she mistakenly took a cup labeled for Hayden and got a mouthful of green tea instead of coffee. Hayden appeared sweaty from a run, and they exchanged drinks amid dry banter about his running. As he left, his watch rang and he answered, “Ms. Ives, hi,” indicating a call from Margaret.
On her drive back, Alice tried to reassure herself that Margaret calling Hayden first might be procedural rather than decisive. She reflected on whom she had told about the opportunity, choosing not to tell her mother but wishing she could share with her late father, who had loved Cosmo’s music and the Margaret–Cosmo love story, including the “Peggy Quartet.”
While driving, Alice received a call from Jodi, who briskly asked her to come for another meeting with Margaret that day, specifying an 8:00 p.m. dinner with a 7:30 p.m. cocktail hour and narrow timing expectations. The call ended abruptly. Alice, reassured by the invitation, felt joy and renewed optimism as her music resumed.
Who Appears
- Alice Scott
narrator and aspiring biographer; experiences caffeine withdrawal, contemplates structure for Margaret’s book, encounters Hayden, and is invited to a second meeting with Margaret.
- Hayden Anderson
rival biographer; meets Alice at the cafe post-run, swaps drinks with her, and takes a call from Margaret.
- Margaret Grace Ives
reclusive subject; calls Hayden and, via Jodi, schedules Alice for a dinner meeting the same evening.
- Jodi
Margaret’s assistant/house manager; calls Alice to set precise timing for the dinner meeting.
- Cosmo
Margaret’s late husband (discussed); songwriter of the “Peggy Quartet,” emblematic of the love story Alice admires.
- Alice’s mother
discussed; someone Alice chose not to tell about the opportunity.
- Alice’s father
discussed; introduced Alice to Cosmo’s music and romanticized Margaret and Cosmo’s story.