Chapter 17

Contains spoilers

Overview

Alice and Hayden share an intense late-night walk in Savannah that turns into a boundary-testing embrace, deepening their mutual attraction while acknowledging their professional constraint. The next morning, Alice reflects on family texts, grief for her father, and relistens to Margaret’s story, capturing how Frederick “Freddy” Ives and Doris “Bernie” Bernhardt fell in love, married, and had daughters Margaret and Laura, before tensions rose when Bernie returned to directing.

Summary

After their diner meet-up, Alice and Hayden wander Savannah’s streets, talking about New York, future plans, and whether Hayden wants children. Hayden voices fears about bringing children into an uncertain world and the burden of witnessing the end of lives through their work. Alice takes his hand and reframes their work as a gift that clarifies priorities, telling him he can only control his actions.

Their connection turns physical but restrained: they kiss each other’s hands, hold each other in a prolonged embrace, and touch intimately without crossing the line into sex, both recognizing “the job” as an unbreachable boundary. Breathless, they separate, and Hayden walks Alice to her car. Alice later tells herself “nothing happened,” despite her body’s reaction.

The next morning, Alice watches the sunrise at the beach and texts her family thread that still includes her late father’s number. Brief exchanges with her mother and sister Audrey stir feelings of inadequacy and grief, and she misses her father’s humor and warmth.

Alice listens to the previous day’s interview recording. Margaret’s account resumes with Freddy Ives sending Doris “Bernie” Bernhardt flowers after her MGM contract and again after her first MGM release, with a note praising her. Their phone calls become regular, then weekly walks follow. Freddy dates others while Bernie does not, until, after eleven months, Freddy proposes during a walk; Bernie kisses him, and they become engaged.

Bernie’s missed period accelerates their wedding. She moves into the House of Ives, attends family events, and bonds with seven-year-old cousin Ruth “LP.” In 1938, their first daughter, Margaret Grace Ives, is born amid fan-magazine attention. Freddy is devoted early on; Bernie feels torn between motherhood and directing.

Three years later, their second daughter, Laura Rose Ives, is born, markedly different in temperament from Margaret. As the girls grow, Bernie worries about both for different reasons. When Margaret turns five and Laura is two, Bernie decides to return to work; despite Freddy’s preference for Royal, she signs with Universal, and their work schedules reduce their walks and increase stress. This is when the parental fighting begins, which is where the interview day ended.

Back on the beach, Alice recalls interviewing her father in college and regrets not recording it. She comforts herself with the idea that love persists beyond loss, sends a simple “Thank you” text to her father’s number, and immediately receives a separate text from Hayden. Their brief exchange ends with Hayden asking what she is doing that night.

Who Appears

  • Alice
    narrator; shares a charged embrace with Hayden, reflects on family texts and grief, reviews Margaret’s interview, and texts Hayden.
  • Hayden
    co-author; opens up about fears of parenthood and work’s burdens, shares intimate but restrained physical moment with Alice, later texts her.
  • Margaret Grace Ives (senior)
    interview subject; in recording, narrates her parents’ courtship, marriage, and early family life; introduced as a newborn within her own story.
  • Frederick “Freddy” Ives
    Margaret’s father; courts Doris “Bernie” Bernhardt, proposes, marries, becomes father to Margaret and Laura, wants Bernie at Royal; key figure in family dynamics.
  • Doris “Bernie” Bernhardt
    director and Margaret’s mother; moves to MGM, marries Freddy, mothers Margaret and Laura, later returns to directing at Universal, triggering marital tension.
  • Laura Rose Ives
    Margaret’s younger sister; new; born three years after Margaret, calm and cautious, contrasts with Margaret.
  • Ruth “LP” (Little Princess)
    Gerald’s secret daughter with Nina and raised as niece; appears in reminiscence as a seven-year-old playing with Bernie; previously revealed as Ruth Allen.
  • Alice’s mother
    appears via texts; practical tone, prompts Alice’s feelings about family.
  • Audrey
    Alice’s sister; appears via texts from a community garden; supportive.
  • Alice’s father
    deceased; present in memory and old interview; his number remains on the family thread, anchoring Alice’s grief and gratitude.
© 2025 SparknotesAI