Preparing for the welcome dinner, Scottie worries the camp might be overtly sexual after their cabin experience. Wilder checks on Scottie’s injury, and they banter about her new black eye and their ongoing plan to appear estranged in public. They also joke about trading the erotic “prizes” in their cabin, reinforcing the camp’s adult theme.

On the walk to the dining hall, they agree to answer any questions about their mini-golf prize diplomatically. Wilder’s improv style clashes with Scottie’s desire to pre-plan, but they continue their playful back-and-forth while staying mindful of their cover.

Inside the dim, intimate dining hall with individual tables, Sanders greets them, comments on Scottie’s black eye, and insinuates the camp’s sex-positive angle. He seats them at a permanent table directly in front of the stage, emphasizing routine and visibility. Scottie privately reconsiders her coworkers through the lens of the erotic cabin amenities and reflects on balanced relationships.

Wilder pulls out Scottie’s chair out of habit, which she notes conflicts with their fake discord but reveals his considerate nature. He explains his mother raised him and Mika to be gentlemen, and Scottie recalls the family’s history, including their father’s accident and death, softening the mood.

Their server, Meghan, introduces alcohol-free dining (except two nights during the stay) and takes their matching eggplant parmesan orders, bringing sparkling water and garlic bread. She gives them a sheet of required nightly questions. The first, a whimsical prompt about superheroes wearing underwear outside their pants, reinforces the camp’s offbeat structure.

Sanders appears unexpectedly to check on them, startling Scottie. After he leaves, Scottie asks Wilder to warn her before Sanders approaches; they agree on the verbal code “colonel” (for Colonel Sanders). Returning to the question, Scottie offers a cheeky answer about superheroes’ costumes providing “extra protection” from prying eyes, making Wilder laugh and ending the scene with comfortable rapport beneath their public pretense.