Scottie and Wilder finish dinner, bantering about a baked potato and Wilder’s love of simple pleasures. Finky invites them to join coworkers at the firepit for s'mores; Scottie wants to avoid the Brads-and-Chad crowd, but Wilder, motivated by his sweet tooth and optimism, agrees and promises a brief appearance.

At the firepit, with Chad, Brad, Duncan, and Finky and their partners assembled, the group proposes Never Have I Ever. Wilder hijacks the game with suggestive prompts that imply an adventurous sex life for him and Scottie, raising eyebrows and fueling curiosity about their “kinky” cabin. The men reveal jealousy over the special erotic cabin, calling it “coveted,” and speculate about its perks, including handcuffs and other items.

Chad presses further, claiming Scottie and Wilder are too conveniently affectionate after earlier arguments and accuses them of faking their struggles to gain attention from Sanders and qualify for extra camp perks, mentioning a rumored “tent.” Wilder grows protective and confrontational, rejecting the accusation and calling out their jealousy and projections. Despite Brad’s half-hearted defense, the group admits envy of the cabin.

Wilder ends the exchange by labeling them “pathetic” and leads Scottie away. Back at the cabin, still seething, he proposes “spreading the wealth.” Over Scottie’s hesitant objections, Wilder gathers the erotic supplies (including a nipple picture, handcuffs, condoms, a vibrator, and a dildo) and returns to the firepit.

In front of everyone, Wilder theatrically distributes the items: the nipple photo to Chad with a taunt, a dildo and lube to Duncan and his husband, handcuffs to Brad, and condoms and a vibrator to Finky, warning them to mind their own business and vowing to block them from getting the “tent.” He then takes Scottie back to their cabin.

Later in bed, Wilder remains angry about the group ganging up on Scottie, while Scottie feels embarrassed and conflicted. Their discussion escalates: Wilder says he was protecting Scottie and rejects pride as his motive; Scottie argues he made things worse and humiliated her among coworkers in a situation that affects her real job. The fight ends in stalemate, with Wilder turning away and Scottie feeling exposed and unsettled, recognizing it felt like their first real argument.