Shaken by how deeply she felt their make-out during the earlier exercise, Scottie rushes to the main building and begs a counselor for a quarter to use the red pay phone. She calls her friend Denise, breathlessly confessing that the kiss with Wilder was intense and physically arousing, and that she is unexpectedly “crushing” on him. Denise encourages Scottie to allow herself to explore the attraction, noting even Mika wouldn’t mind, but the call drops as Scottie admits she’s afraid of getting attached and then being hurt.

Scottie composes herself and rejoins Wilder by the lake. Wilder tries to open a conversation about the kiss meaning something, but Sanders calls them to cocktail hour. Sanders praises them as the “hottest couple” and seats them at a table with food, strong rum cocktails, and a custom card game where each answered question requires a drink.

The Q&A turns sexual immediately. Scottie admits her fantasy is climaxing while a partner is inside her, which Wilder pointedly blames her ex Matt for not fulfilling. When asked his porn preference, Wilder says he likes sensual, authentic scenes. He confronts Scottie for acting like their kiss meant nothing and says he “felt that…through [his] entire…body.” The questions escalate: Scottie describes how she masturbates; Wilder says he prefers being loud and wants his partner coming on his cock.

Wilder answers that he’d like Scottie in “no” underwear and vividly describes an office-tease scenario culminating in spanking and sex, revealing he has a genital piercing. Scottie is flustered; Sanders briefly checks in, amused by their charged dynamic. Wilder keeps needling Scottie for a genuine reaction, tugging his lip ring and asking where she likes to be kissed; when she evasively says “cheek,” he suggests she prefers oral sex.

The exchange exposes the core tension: Wilder admits he’s being provocative to draw out Scottie after she minimized their kiss, while Scottie retorts that he refused a public fondling earlier. Pressed, Scottie deflects with “maybe it was nothing,” which visibly hurts Wilder. He asks if she truly felt nothing; she backpedals but cannot give a clear affirmation, and Wilder leaves, saying he needs the bathroom, frustrated and stung.