Chapter 40
Contains spoilersOverview
Evelyn and Celia confront the emotional and logistical realities of Evelyn having a baby with Harry. Celia fears she cannot give Evelyn motherhood and struggles with not wanting children, but ultimately consents to the plan for privacy reasons and vows to be Aunt Celia. Their intimacy seals a fragile, momentous agreement that will shape their shared future.
Summary
In bed after making love, Evelyn and Celia discuss the child Evelyn wants with Harry. Celia presses for clarity: the baby would be raised by both Evelyn and Celia, and they would figure out how John and Celia fit into the family. Evelyn emphasizes that it would be their child emotionally and domestically, even if not biologically Celia’s.
Celia admits she has never wanted children and worries she cannot give Evelyn what Evelyn desires. Evelyn reassures Celia that this does not diminish their relationship and that Celia has already given her more than she ever imagined. The conversation shifts to logistics: Celia raises donor insemination, but Evelyn is concerned about discretion and believes intercourse with Harry is the most secure option to protect their privacy.
Needing reassurance, Celia asks whether Evelyn’s love and commitment remain centered on their partnership. Evelyn affirms that Celia is the person she loves and makes a life with, and that sex with Harry would be a means to conceive, not a romantic choice. With that assurance, Celia consents: if Evelyn wants a baby, they will make it work, and Celia will embrace the role of Aunt Celia as they define the boundaries together.
The scene closes with the couple reaffirming their bond through intimacy. Evelyn frames Celia’s consent and emotional generosity as the gift that enables Evelyn’s path to motherhood, a decision that quietly but decisively sets their future in motion.
Who Appears
- Evelyn Hugo
Proposes and defends having a baby with Harry for privacy; reassures Celia of her primacy; seeks a shared family plan.
- Celia St. James
Admits she doesn’t want children and can’t provide that, but consents to the plan and commits to being Aunt Celia.
- Harry Cameron
Offstage; intended biological father due to privacy concerns, representing the practical method for conception.
- John Braverman
Offstage; his role in the foursome is considered as they discuss how he and Celia would fit around the baby.