Chapter 1

Contains spoilers

Overview

Evie meets Ryan’s lifelong friends at a dinner where she carefully manages their probing questions and withholds details about her past. Privately, she reveals she engineered their flat-tire meet-cute, signaling calculated intent. A lunch invitation follows stalled social media searches. Ryan asks her to move in, and she accepts, raising emotional stakes and risk.

Summary

Small signs of cohabitation have accumulated in Ryan’s house, and now Evie faces the next step: a dinner with Ryan’s lifelong friends. She notes how the women immediately register the feminine touches in his home and how every answer she gives will be scrutinized.

Beth questions Evie’s unusual name, and Evie explains it’s short for Evelyn, after her grandmother. Allison presses for where Evie is from; Evie offers only “a small town in Alabama,” and Ryan diverts the conversation. Evie observes the group’s insular background and envies their easy familiarity while bracing for judgment.

When Sara asks how Evie and Ryan met, Evie chooses a minimal story: he helped change her flat tire. She withholds that she worked at the truck stop bar and holds only a GED, aware such facts could bias them. Cole jokes Ryan might have flattened the tire to meet her, and Ryan lets Evie steer the narrative.

Internally, Evie admits she orchestrated the encounter. She had watched Ryan’s routines, noted his Thursday gas stop, and created the flat by holding a nail to the valve, ensuring a meet-cute with shared touchpoints. “I totally nailed it,” she thinks, revealing her calculated approach.

After the guests leave, Ryan says they loved her, but Evie doubts it. A text from Ray reports that Sara wants Evie’s number for a lunch, confirming deeper curiosity after social media searches yielded little. In an intimate moment, Ryan asks her to stay every night and make the house her home; Evie agrees, and the chapter closes with them moving toward a shared life.

Who Appears

  • Evie (Evelyn)
    Narrator; manages scrutiny at dinner, conceals her past, reveals she engineered meeting Ryan, agrees to move in.
  • Ryan
    Boyfriend from a close-knit town; supports Evie, hosts friends, and asks her to move in.
  • Allison
    Ryan’s friend; enthusiastic, asks where Evie is from; married to Cole.
  • Beth
    Friend who calls Evie’s name unusual, prompting Evie’s explanation.
  • Sara
    Friend who asks how Evie and Ryan met; later seeks Evie’s number for lunch.
  • Cole
    Allison’s husband; jokes Ryan might have flattened the tire to meet Evie.
  • Ray
    Friend who texts Ryan, relaying Sara’s request for Evie’s number.
© 2025 SparknotesAI