Chapter 23

Contains spoilers

Overview

Evie meets Atlanta detectives in a hotel suite arranged by Rachel, who controls the interview and instructs Evie to reveal nothing extra. Evie explains her Regina alias as protection from an abusive ex. The detectives first show inconclusive surveillance, then unveil a clear video of Evie in Amy Holder’s room moments before the fatal fire, sharply escalating the threat.

Summary

Evie arrives at the Westin in Atlanta on time to meet Rachel, with Ryan attempting to talk to her before being left in the lobby. Rachel has shifted the police interview from the station to a hotel meeting room for better optics, and she advises Evie to answer only with permission and to reveal nothing extra.

Detectives West and Crofton arrive, record the session, and open by asking why Evie lived as Regina Hale. Evie delivers a cover story about fleeing an abusive ex, Justin Burns, whose police-captain brother could have buried prior incidents, and the detectives note they will verify.

Pressed about Amy Holder, Rachel pushes them to show their evidence. They play hotel exterior footage: Amy entering the American Hotel, clearly intoxicated, with only a blurry background figure resembling Evie. Rachel attacks it as inconclusive and reiterates the official accident finding of a smoking-related fire.

Detectives then present an “eyewitness” video from across the street: a clear view through Amy’s balcony doors shows Evie, in a housekeeping uniform, looking toward the bed and producing matches moments before thick smoke fills the room. Evie recognizes the moment; she and Devon had only recently learned of the video and suspect added audio and Mr. Smith’s involvement. The evidence significantly heightens the risk to Evie.

Who Appears

  • Evelyn Porter (Evie)
    Protagonist; attends hotel interview, gives abusive-ex cover for her alias, appears clearly in incriminating video.
  • Rachel Murray
    Evie’s attorney; moves meeting to hotel, manages optics, challenges evidence, directs Evie’s limited responses.
  • Detective West
    Lead questioner; presses about alias and Amy, presents surveillance and eyewitness videos.
  • Detective Crofton
    Partner detective; handles recorder and iPad, plays videos during the interview.
  • Amy Holder
    Deceased subject; seen entering hotel and as the occupant of the room shown in the fire video.
  • Ryan
    Evie’s boyfriend; tries to speak to her before the interview, waits in the lobby.
© 2025 SparknotesAI