Theo leaves Golden in early December because business duties require his attention in New York. He plans to spend Christmas and New Year’s Eve in the city, and he is immediately struck by the harsher cold and snow after landing at LaGuardia, missing Golden and especially his Promenade neighbors.

Rather than escaping holiday obligations, Theo prepares in advance to stay emotionally present in Golden by arranging Christmas gifts to be delivered while he is away. Three days before Christmas, Anita Gidley goes to the Verbivore and awkwardly introduces herself to Tony Wilcox, then hands him an elegantly wrapped box and a typed note instructing him not to open it until Christmas morning. Tony is surprised by the anonymous generosity, accepts the gift, and watches her leave, newly aware of how little they have spoken despite years as neighbors.

Mrs. Gidley then visits the college music school to find Simone practicing cello and delivers his package and letter as well. Simone is grateful and takes the gift home the next day. Over two days, Mrs. Gidley delivers a dozen or more gifts across Theo’s circle of friends, and the recipients’ happiness affects her; she recognizes she is tasting the kind of joy Theo described in his earlier anonymous giving.

Each gift includes a handwritten letter from Theo with personal gratitude, encouragement, and references to the Christ child. Simone receives a high-quality Emil Werner cello bow, precisely the kind he had once mentioned wanting, along with Theo’s charge to use it well. Eight-year-old Lamisha receives art supplies, the full Wingfeather Saga set, and bright blue dress shoes, paired with a note affirming her unique worth and belovedness.

For Ellen, Theo bases his choice on her “featherwood” craft: he sends practical tools (a foldable handsaw, compact cordless sander and drill, and a wood burner) plus a Portuguese cashmere scarf. Jason from the bike shop delivers the large box to Ellen at the Mission on Christmas Eve, along with Theo’s detailed letter suggesting she consider selling her work. Theo even sketches a simple feather logo and the name “Oxbow Featherwood,” and Ellen, buoyed by his praise and confidence, resolves not to disappoint him.