Wrapped in Charlie's winter coat and accompanied by Shylo, Eve leaves the house determined not to return. Near the end of the driveway, Eve sees Thomas speaking privately with Charlie and immediately fears Thomas is presenting Eve as unstable. Eve resists rushing in, knowing that defending herself too forcefully might only make Charlie doubt her more.

Once Thomas drives away, Eve gets into Charlie's truck and urgently asks to leave the property. Charlie explains that Thomas told her Eve had been acting strangely, had gone into the attic, fallen, hit her head, and then claimed she saw a woman there. Because Thomas's version is built from real events, Eve cannot simply dismiss it, so she tests Charlie another way: Eve asks whether the upstairs study has a stained-glass window. When Charlie says yes, Eve reveals that the window is now an ordinary one.

The impossible change unsettles both of them, especially because it echoes earlier stories about the house changing. Charlie still tries to reason through it, but she agrees they should spend the night somewhere else. Eve feels briefly safe when Charlie comforts her, yet Eve still cannot bring herself to explain everything else she has seen, including the cabin stranger and what Heather said about Thomas.

Charlie then insists on going back inside for a charger and clean clothes, despite Eve's repeated warnings. Eve stays in the truck with Shylo, anxiously watching the house while Charlie moves through the bedroom upstairs. After a tense wait, Charlie returns with a bag and immediately confirms that the window has changed. Shaken but still grasping for a practical explanation, Charlie drives them away, while Eve hopes she has seen the house for the last time and Mo suggests she has not escaped it so easily.