Chapter 4

Contains spoilers

Overview

The chapter is a flashback to a private moment between Talia (Kemper) and Noel as they plan their wedding. After Noel fails to book their dream venue, Talia proposes impersonating the current reservation holder to force a cancellation, but Noel insists he should make the call because he is the better liar. The scene underscores Noel's ease with deception and their dynamic, before abruptly revealing it was a dream as Talia wakes in her prison cell.

Summary

Talia confronts Noel in their bedroom after he admits he did not reserve "the Vineyard" for their planned June first wedding date. She reveals the venue has already been booked by Marie Machudo and Albert Swecker, and expresses frustration that she warned Noel venues fill up a year in advance.

Noel is apologetic and visibly guilty, while Talia reflects that marrying Noel matters more to her than the location. Nonetheless, determined to salvage her preferred venue, she considers calling the Vineyard to impersonate Marie to cancel the existing reservation.

Noel reacts with surprise and disapproval, labeling lying as objectively wrong, but Talia remains undeterred and begins to place the call. Noel snatches her phone, insisting he will handle it instead, arguing that Talia is a poor actor and that he is a much better liar. He proposes to impersonate Albert Swecker to secure the venue for themselves.

Talia feels a sudden, disorienting sense that the moment is unreal, as if replaying a memory. She reassures herself and accepts Noel’s plan, acknowledging his skill at deception. The intimate scene culminates with Noel leaning in to kiss her.

Before their lips meet, the illusion breaks: Talia wakes up in her prison cell, confirming the entire exchange was a dream or memory replay.

Who Appears

  • Talia (Kemper)
    narrator; argues with Noel about their wedding venue; contemplates impersonation; awakens in her prison cell.
  • Noel Kemper
    Talia’s fiancé/husband; failed to book the wedding venue; offers to impersonate Albert Swecker, emphasizing he is a better liar.
  • Marie Machudo
    new; name on the conflicting wedding reservation at the Vineyard; not physically present.
  • Albert Swecker
    new; name on the conflicting reservation; Noel plans to impersonate him; not physically present.
© 2025 SparknotesAI