Chapter Eleven: That Summer

Contains spoilers

Overview

CPS arrives to interview Eugene, but Hannah refuses to let him be questioned alone. Watching via a hidden camera, Mia recognizes the consultant’s AAC letterboard focus, triggering a full recounting of That Summer. A past PSW experiment briefly buoyed the family until Adam’s blind test exposed facilitator influence, devastating Hannah and reshaping family roles.

Summary

Mia describes the shock of a scheduled CPS visit proceeding amid new leads in Adam’s disappearance. Detective Janus insists on interviewing Eugene alone; Hannah refuses, asserting parental presence. Mia and John retreat inside and covertly watch the porch via a nanny cam their father installed.

The CPS consultant introduces herself as a speech pathologist specializing in AAC with letterboards/keyboards. Seeing Hannah blanch, Mia anticipates failure and recalls the family’s fraught history with assisted writing that nearly broke her parents apart.

Mia recounts That Summer: after years of anxiety and maternal guilt—amplified by insinuations that Angelman’s error is “maternal”—Hannah embraced physically supported writing (PSW) with a trainee, TFT. Early sessions calmed Eugene, and a striking moment (“my throat hurts”) preceded a strep diagnosis, igniting Hannah’s hope and lifting the household mood.

During a rare at-home session, Adam asked to pose questions. He had secretly prepared a verification: he’d introduced a new red ball and a different bedtime book. When asked simple questions, Eugene/TFT produced plausible but incorrect answers. Adam then revealed a paper listing the true answers, proving facilitator influence.

TFT reacted defiantly; Hannah expelled her. Afterward, anger shifted to Adam for orchestrating a public “gotcha” that maximized Hannah’s fall from hope. Mia confronted Adam for the cruelty of the reveal. The fallout nearly ended the marriage and precipitated a role reversal: Hannah returned to full-time work while Adam stayed home.

Back in the present, the arrival of an AAC-focused CPS consultant explains Hannah’s resistance and the family’s skepticism, raising stakes for extracting any information from Eugene about Adam’s disappearance.

Who Appears

  • Mia
    Narrator; watches the CPS interview via nanny cam and recounts That Summer’s facilitated-communication debacle.
  • Hannah (Mom)
    Refuses to let Eugene be questioned alone; past hope and guilt tied to PSW; expels TFT; later returns to work.
  • Adam
    Missing father in present; in flashback, stages a blind test exposing facilitator influence, causing family rupture.
  • Eugene
    Nonspeaking son; subject of CPS interview; past PSW client whose apparent messages were facilitator-driven.
  • Detective Janus
    Leads investigation; insists on interviewing Eugene without family, prompting Hannah’s firm refusal.
  • John
    Mia’s twin; helps access the nanny cam; sides with Hannah during the fallout in the flashback.
  • CPS Consultant (Speech Pathologist)
    Young AAC specialist focused on letterboards; her arrival triggers the family’s painful PSW memories.
  • TFT
    Past PSW facilitator; early ‘successes’ undone by Adam’s test; expelled after reacting combatively.
© 2025 SparknotesAI