The House of Doors
by Tan Twan Eng
Contents
Chapter Fifteen
Overview
Ethel Proudlock's murder trial unfolds in Kuala Lumpur, with testimony from her husband, witnesses, police, and doctors painting conflicting pictures of an attempted rape versus a jealous killing. Lesley commits perjury under oath, denying knowledge of Ethel's affair with Steward. Despite Ethel's emotional defence, the judge and both assessors find her guilty, and she is sentenced to hang.
Summary
In Kuala Lumpur, Ethel Proudlock's murder trial opens before Mr Justice Sercombe Smith and two European assessors. Lesley, seated in the front row, observes Ethel looking gaunt and hostile. Prosecutor Hastings Rhodes calls William Proudlock first. William testifies about the events of 23 April: target practice in the garden, handing the loaded Webley to Ethel, leaving for Evensong, then dining alone at Goodman Ambler's house while Ethel stayed home in a tea gown. He recounts her bloodied, dishevelled return and her account of Steward attacking her, switching off the light, and groping her until she shot him. Rhodes insinuates impropriety, noting the revealing tea gown and that William had been away in Hong Kong for a month, with friend Hugh Markes checking on Ethel.
Goodman Ambler corroborates William's account, adding that Ethel cried "He made me do it" and was hysterical. Detective Inspector Wyatt describes the body forty paces from the verandah, the revolver with six spent cartridges, and Ethel's blood-smeared, powder-blackened hand. Dr McIntyre testifies that on the night of the shooting Ethel showed no bruises and seemed unexpectedly composed, but a day later he found five bruises consistent with assault. Under Pooley's cross-examination, McIntyre concedes Ethel is nervous and hysterical and could have suffered temporary loss of reason.
The prosecution then introduces damaging evidence: Inspector Ferrant found European women's and a young girl's clothing at Steward's Salak South house, and witness George Spence confirms Steward had been living with a Chinese woman for three months. The prosecution implies Ethel killed Steward in jealous rage upon discovering this affair.
On the fourth day, Pooley calls Lesley. Facing Ethel directly, Lesley commits perjury, denying that Ethel ever confided an affair with Steward and asserting the rumours are baseless. Rhodes declines to cross-examine. Ethel then testifies, denying any affair, recounting Steward's unexpected arrival, his violent advances, and her grabbing the revolver in desperation. She declares she would rather be convicted of murder than live branded as an unfaithful wife.
After closing arguments, both assessors Wise and Kindersley return verdicts of guilty, and Mr Justice Smith concurs. Ethel stays silent when offered a chance to speak. The judge sentences her to hang. Ethel collapses, wailing, clinging to William until policemen pull her into a van bound for Pudoh Gaol, with Lesley and the lawyers watching helplessly.
Who Appears
- Lesley HamlynNarrator and witness; commits perjury under oath, denying Ethel confided an affair with Steward.
- Ethel ProudlockDefendant; testifies Steward tried to rape her, denies any affair, is convicted of murder and sentenced to hang.
- William ProudlockEthel's husband and schoolmaster; testifies about the gun and Ethel's account, defends her character.
- James PooleySenior defence counsel who builds a case of temporary insanity from attempted rape.
- Hastings RhodesPublic Prosecutor who insinuates Ethel killed Steward in jealous rage over a rival mistress.
- Mr Justice Sercombe SmithPresiding judge who concurs with the assessors' guilty verdict and sentences Ethel to death.
- WagnerLawyer who reserved Lesley's courtroom seat and prepared her testimony.
- Goodman AmblerWilliam's friend; corroborates events and recounts Ethel's hysterical statements after the shooting.
- Detective Inspector Charles WyattPolice inspector who examined the scene, body, and the bloodied revolver.
- Dr Edward McIntyreSurgeon who found no bruises initially but five later; deems Ethel nervous and hysterical.
- Inspector Frederick FerrantSearched Steward's house and found European women's and a young girl's clothing.
- George SpenceSteward's friend; confirms Steward lived with a Chinese woman for three months.
- William StewardThe deceased; portrayed as either Ethel's would-be rapist or her secret lover and victim of jealousy.
- ArthurLesley's lover, longed for in her hotel room during the trial.
- Mr Wise and Mr KindersleyEuropean assessors who both return guilty verdicts against Ethel.