13 An Unfair Advantage

Contains spoilers

Overview

Iris Winnow returned to the Oath Gazette grieving her mother’s death and struggled to maintain composure. Zeb Autry awarded the columnist position to Roman Kitt, who publicly revealed Iris’s bereavement to argue for more time for her, but Zeb refused. Confronted with her grief and new priorities, Iris resigned from the Gazette despite Roman’s pleas for her to stay. She left determined to move on, with thoughts turning toward finding her brother, Forest.

Summary

Iris came back to the newsroom feeling transformed by grief even as the office remained unchanged. Avoiding personal conversation, she deflected Sarah Prindle and endured Roman Kitt’s concern, rebuffing his questions about why she had abruptly left work previously. Summoned by Zeb Autry, Iris failed to produce her essay; Zeb scolded her for not calling in and dismissed her excuses. Back at her desk, Iris typed her mother Aster Winnow’s obituary, struggling through tears.

The next day Iris arrived late to find Zeb waiting. In his office, with Roman present, Zeb announced his decision: Roman had won the columnist position based on his published piece about missing soldiers. Roman, tense and unenthusiastic, asked Zeb to grant both candidates more time, citing an unfair advantage.

Roman then revealed that Iris’s mother had recently died, information he gleaned from reading Iris’s obituary copy. The disclosure shocked Iris, and Zeb, after a brief expression of sympathy, upheld his decision and offered Iris bereavement leave. The exchange exposed Roman’s attentiveness to Iris’s work and unsettled Iris further.

Realizing that time off would leave her alone with her grief and that her career ambitions no longer outweighed her family concerns, Iris decided to resign. She formally quit on the spot, congratulated Roman, and began packing her belongings. Sarah expressed concern and sadness at her departure, and the newsroom fell silent as Iris prepared to leave.

Zeb handed Iris her final paycheck. At the door, Roman blocked her path, urging her not to go and challenging her impulse to hide her pain by retracting her public obituary for her mother. When Roman called her “Iris,” the intimacy rattled her, but she insisted on leaving.

Iris exited the Gazette without looking back, feeling lighter for having claimed a new direction. Internally, she resolved to pursue what now mattered most: finding her brother Forest at the front.

Who Appears

  • Iris Winnow
    reporter; grieving her mother; writes Aster’s obituary; loses columnist race; resigns from the Oath Gazette with intent to change course toward finding Forest.
  • Roman Kitt
    rival reporter; awarded columnist position; reveals Iris’s bereavement to argue for more time; reads Iris’s work closely; urges Iris to stay and calls her by her given name.
  • Zeb Autry
    editor; reprimands Iris; awards column to Roman; offers bereavement leave but accepts Iris’s resignation.
  • Sarah Prindle
    colleague; checks on Iris, offers to reassign obituaries; expresses sadness at Iris’s resignation.
  • Aster Winifred Winnow
    Iris’s mother; deceased; subject of the obituary Iris types this chapter.
  • Forest Winnow
    Iris’s brother; away at the western front; motivates Iris’s decision to leave and consider searching for him.
© 2025 SparknotesAI