The protagonist returned home to find a single flower left on their porch.
They called their friend Kyle and arranged to meet to discuss their findings from Boston.
The protagonist told Kyle that Bethany had murdered James Finley, and that she was an identity thief targeting their life.
They revealed that Bethany had potentially tried to frame them for the murder by locating the scene near their home and place of work.
The protagonist also uncovered an anonymous call implicating Davis Cobb in a dispute with a woman near the lake. This led to Cobb's arrest, further shifting suspicion away from Bethany.
Walking around the back of their home, they found a gnome statue that smelled faintly of bleach -- implying that it was the weapon used to attack Bethany and left near the lake.
The protagonist suggested that their friend Emmy was actually a figment of their imagination, leaving them lost and confused.